Mac Jeffrey
English 1100
Prof. Young
Language
September 13, 2015
Language
It is a common discussion weather or not students should be able to write like they talk in school assignments. I think that both sides of the argument have truth and I'm not totally sure there is a right answer to the question, but it is definitely worth taking a closer look at. It was a rule with most of my teachers in high school that we weren't able to write like we talk and I have to say I never really understood that rule. After all, we do have freedom of speech in this country. After looking back, I think the purpose of that rule was probably to prepare us for the real world because you might not be able to write exactly how you talk if you are writing a letter to your boss or any other authority figure. Also, if you write in Academic English, it is pretty much universally recognized so it is a safer bet when you aren't sure how to phrase an essay. On the other hand, the style of writing that most teachers teach gives you no authenticity. I think writing should reflect your unique personality and writing in Academic English might not be your preferred style. Some people speak more properly, and some people like to throw a lot of slang into their speech. Of coarse, every student's writing still has to be understandable to the teacher. The question becomes where do you draw the line between authentic and proper? There has to be a bit of both in a student's writing. If the whole thing has to be in proper English, the students might not be being true to themselves. If it is in total modern day slang, it might not be readable for the teacher. The student must be able to write clearly while still being true to who they are. A great example of using your own language is in the song "Fuck Tha Police" by NWA. They talk about all of the terrible things they have seen the police force in Compton do. While a lot of people will have a problem with this song, I think that it was somewhat appropriate them for them to say what they said. They are talking about what they know to be true and they are getting their anger out by rapping. However, it is wrong to assume this about all police and it could cause some people to rebel.
